Jump to Recipe
Air Fryer French Toast Sticks (Crispy + Custard Inside) — American Baking recipe, 17 min, serves 4American

Air Fryer French Toast Sticks (Crispy + Custard Inside)

Published ·Updated ·by ·✓ Editorially Reviewed
↓ Jump to Recipe
VegetarianHigh protein

Brioche bread, vanilla-cinnamon custard, and 9 minutes in the air fryer. Golden crisp outside, soft custard inside — coffee-shop quality at home in 17 minutes total.

17
min
8
prep
🔥
9
cook
👥
4
servings
320
kcal / serving
🛍 Buy IngredientsPin
Share:
4

Ingredients

Our top picks for this recipe

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

Most popular
Cosori Pro 5.8L Air Fryer

Most-recommended air fryer for home cooking. 5.8 L basket fits 4 servings, accurate temperature (verified ±2 °C), dishwasher-safe basket.

$120-150Check price on Amazon →
Best value
Air Fryer Parchment Liners (100ct)

Pre-cut perforated parchment for the basket — air still circulates, but cleanup is one step. The single biggest convenience upgrade.

$10-15Check price on Amazon →
Editor's pick
ThermoPro Instant-Read Thermometer

The most reliable doneness signal for any protein. Stops the guesswork — chicken at 74 °C, salmon at 63 °C, every time.

$15-25Check price on Amazon →

Instructions

1

Cut brioche slices into 4 sticks each (so 32 sticks total).

💡 Day-old bread is firmer — absorbs custard without falling apart.
2

Whisk eggs, milk, cream, 2 tbsp sugar, vanilla, 1 tsp cinnamon, nutmeg and salt until smooth.

3

Dip each stick in custard for 3-4 seconds per side. Don't soak — over-soaked bread becomes mushy.

💡 Quick dip is essential. Long soak = soggy interior, won't crisp.
4

Place sticks in single layer in air fryer. Mist with oil or brush with melted butter.

5

Air fry at 190 °C (375 °F) for 7-9 minutes, flipping at 4 min, until golden brown.

8:00
6

Meanwhile, mix 50 g sugar and 1 tbsp cinnamon in a shallow dish.

7

Toss hot sticks in cinnamon-sugar immediately while still hot.

💡 Sugar adheres to the surface oil/butter — must be hot to stick.
8

Serve immediately with maple syrup for dipping.

💡 French toast sticks lose texture within 10 minutes. Eat fresh.

More tools we recommend

Premium pick
Ninja Foodi DualZone 8L XL

Two independent baskets for cooking protein + side at once. Best for families of 4+ or batch cookers. Premium pick.

$180-230Check price on Amazon →
Essential
Silicone Tongs (2-pack)

Won't scratch the non-stick basket. Heat-safe to 230 °C. The right tool to flip wings, drumsticks, and crispy bits without damage.

$10-15Check price on Amazon →
Eco-friendly
Reusable Silicone Air Fryer Mat

Skip parchment liners entirely. Dishwasher safe, lasts years, fits standard 5-6 L baskets. Better long-term cost than disposables.

$10-18Check price on Amazon →
Save your rating

How was this recipe?

Saved on your device only — no public reviews shown.
Thanks for rating!

Common Questions

Best bread?
Brioche, challah, or thick-sliced French bread. Avoid sandwich bread — too thin, falls apart.
Can I make ahead?
Pre-coat in custard, freeze on a tray, then bag. Cook frozen at 190 °C for 12 minutes.
Without dairy?
Substitute milk + cream with oat milk + 1 tbsp coconut cream. Texture is similar.
How to keep crisp?
Serve immediately. They lose crisp within 10 min. If holding briefly, keep in a warm oven at 80 °C uncovered.
Serve with?
Maple syrup, berry compote, whipped cream, Greek yogurt, or chocolate sauce.

What to drink with this

🍷
Wine
Zinfandel or California Cabernet — bold reds match smoke and umami.
🍺
Beer
American IPA or amber ale.
🍸
Cocktail
Old Fashioned with a bourbon base.
🥤
Non-alcoholic
Sparkling water with lemon or a craft root beer.

Ingredient substitutions

IngredientReplace withRatioNotes
heavy creamcoconut cream (full-fat, scooped)1:1Dairy-free. Slight coconut flavor — works for curries, less so for European dishes.
evaporated milk + 1 tbsp butter per cup1:1Less rich, but mimics heavy cream in sauces.
sugarerythritol1:1Zero-glycemic. Slight cooling sensation on tongue.
monk fruit blend1:1Zero-glycemic, no aftertaste.

Why this recipe works

Pro tips

Recipe variations

Common mistakes to avoid

The story behind this recipe ▾
French toast (pain perdu = lost bread) was a way to use stale bread in medieval Europe. The 'stick' format came from American fast-food breakfast menus — handy for dipping in syrup with one hand. The air fryer version skips pan-frying without losing the crisp.
🍳Build your own air fryer recipeFree recipe generator — pick an ingredient + flavour, get a recipe instantly.Try it →
This recipe is for inspiration only. We do not provide food safety, storage, or nutritional advice. Always follow your local food safety guidelines. Check all ingredients for allergens.
Start Cooking

Shopping List

🛍 Buy Ingredients

Cook's tips